Gray Eyebrow Pencils: Where Can We Find Them?

You never had to think about these things when you were young. But it's inevitable: Just like the hair on your head goes gray, so do your eyebrows. And yet, who in the world makes gray eyebrow pencil? Get the scoop....


QUESTION: I finally got my mother turned on to the right shade for her eyebrows about two years ago, Maybelline Charcoal Gray. I bought her a package of two. Now that she has used them, we've exhausted ourselves looking for it. I know that Maybelline discontinued this product (great mistake on their behalf). Not all gray-haired people can use the light blond the company suggests. Any ideas?

ANSWER: Searching for the brow pencil turned up a lot of complaints that Maybelline discontinued this shade. However, (via the Makeup Warehouse) does have the Expert Eyes Twin Brow and Eye Pencils in charcoal gray. It's a bit pricey $18.38 but this is the shade you're looking for.

Another option is Aura Cosmetics' pro pencil, which is available for $8.95 at, which is based in Kent, Wash. You can also call (253) 854-1366. The website says "this is a light-medium gray and is terrific for gray and silver hair." It can also double as a smoky eyeliner.

Print Article