More Patients Should Review Doctors

The Reliability of Patient Reviews


The next time you read a review of a doctor on a patient-evaluation site, don’t take it too seriously.

A recent study found that on many physician-review websites, there are an average of just 2.4 patients evaluating each physician.

"Consumers should be cautious when they look at these ratings," first author Chandy Ellimoottil, MD, of the Loyola University Medical School’s Department of Urology, said in a statement. “These sites have potential to help inform consumers. But the sites need more reviews to make them more reliable."

The researchers focused on 500 randomly selected urologists and found that 79.6 of them were rated by at least one of ten free physician-review websites. Eighty-six percent of the urologists had positive ratings, while 36 percent had “highly positive” ratings. But since so few patients review the physicians, a few highly positive or negative review could skew the ratings, Ellimoottil said.

Among the websites, the researchers found, according to a Loyola University news release, that Healthgrades posted reviews on 54 percent of the physicians, followed in order by, 45 percent of physicians;, 39 percent;, 25 percent; Drscore, 13 percent;, 5 percent; and, 1 percent; and and, less than 1 percent.

The findings were published in the Journal of Urology

Free Diabetic Recipe Book
Get your free meal guide and recipe booklet today, packed with more than 60 recipes to help you or your loved ones better manage diabetes symptoms.
Click here to get yours!

Print Article